Humidifier Vs Vaporizer

Humidifier vs Vaporizer:  The Great Debate

For anyone that suffers from nosebleeds, allergies or cold symptoms, the decision between purchasing a humidifier vs vaporizer always brings up a great number of questions along with a lot of confusion.  While they both increase the moisture quantity in the air, they are both very different appliances.

When your home is dry, your nasal passages also become dry.  By adding moisture into the air that you are breathing, it prevents bacteria from leaching onto your nasal passages.  Both machines ultimately create moisture so which one do you choose?


When deciding between a humidifier vs vaporizer, it is helpful to look at the pros and cons of both of them individually.  A humidifier can be used in one room or an entire home as there are furnace humidifiers that actually connect to the HVAC system in your home to improve the air quality when the heat is running.

Evaporative humidifiers are most commonly referred to in the humidifier vs vaporizer debate.  It consists of a wick, fan and reservoir.  The wick absorbs the reservoir's water and acts as a filter where the moisture is expelled into the air by a fan.

The disadvantage of these types of humidifiers is that if the wick is not able to dry out between uses, it can become moldy and filled with mineral deposits.  Additionally, if the humidity reaches over 60 percent and a humidifier is still used, it can enhance the growth of mold and reproduction of dust mites in your home.  They can also cause humidifier lung.  Because of these concerns, most newer models reduce bacteria and mold growth by using the Microban Technology.


The more favorable appliance for most homes, especially with children, in the humidifier vs vaporizer debate is the cold air vaporizer.  It consists of a drum, spout and a water reservoir and it emits vapor into the air that is created by a spinning disk.  Since the water is not heated before being expelled, it makes this appliance the more practical choice for a child's room.

Some health care professionals prefer and recommend the humidifier in the humidifier vs vaporizer debate because vaporizers are more suitable to harbor bacteria since the water is not heated.  Additionally, vaporizers are more prone to release tap water minerals into the air as well.

Despite these downfalls, most parents choose a vaporizer for their child's room because they do not run the risk of being burned by putting their face or hand over the steam.  By using a cool air vaporizer, the risk of burn is eliminated.

To eliminate any bacteria being dispersed into the air, the reservoir and other mechanisms need to be cleaned between fillings with soapy water.

Decision Time

Only you can decide which appliance in the humidifier vs vaporizer debate is the right choice for you, your home and family.  Keep in mind that while vaporizers do help quite a bit in smaller areas of the house such as a child's room, humidifiers are more suitable for an entire house.


Both machines will create moisture to help relieve dry nasal passages and both have their own warning labels.  Always follow the manufacturer guidelines for use and make a point to clean them between uses.  A dirty machine will ultimately be doing you and your home much more harm than good by releasing bacteria into the air.

When using humidifiers anywhere around your home, be sure that they are out of reach of children and pets that could be burned by the steam or that could knock the appliance over or trip on the cord and be scalded by the hot water.